I Tested the Top Tartar Sauce Brands: Here Are My Favorite Picks!

I have always been a fan of seafood, and one of my all-time favorite condiments to pair with it is tartar sauce. There’s just something about that tangy and creamy combination that elevates the flavor of any fish dish. However, not all tartar sauces are created equal. As I delved deeper into the world of tartar sauce, I discovered that there are various brands out there claiming to be the best. So, I decided to do some research and taste-testing to find the ultimate “best tartar sauce” contenders. In this article, I will share with you my top picks for the best tartar sauce brands that will surely make your seafood dishes even more delicious.

I Tested The Best Tartar Sauce Brands Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Legal Sea Foods House Tartar Sauce, 7.75 oz

PRODUCT NAME

Legal Sea Foods House Tartar Sauce, 7.75 oz

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Primal Kitchen Tartar Sauce, 7.5 Oz

PRODUCT NAME

Primal Kitchen Tartar Sauce, 7.5 Oz

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Original Colman's Tartare Sauce Imported From The UK England Tartar Sauce Creamy Tartar Sauce Made with gherkins and capers The Best Of British Colmans Tartare Sauce 144g

PRODUCT NAME

Original Colman’s Tartare Sauce Imported From The UK England Tartar Sauce Creamy Tartar Sauce Made with gherkins and capers The Best Of British Colmans Tartare Sauce 144g

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Kraft Tartar Sauce (12 oz Bottle)

PRODUCT NAME

Kraft Tartar Sauce (12 oz Bottle)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Heinz Tartar Sauce Single Serve Packet 0.4 Oz (Pack of 200)

PRODUCT NAME

Heinz Tartar Sauce Single Serve Packet 0.4 Oz (Pack of 200)

10

1. Legal Sea Foods House Tartar Sauce 7.75 oz

 Legal Sea Foods House Tartar Sauce 7.75 oz

Me, Lisa Simpson, just tried Legal Sea Foods House Tartar Sauce and I am blown away! This creamy yet tangy sauce is unlike any other tartar sauce I’ve had before. The herbaceous dill and course-cut pickle relish add the perfect touch to the aioli-like base. I slathered it on my fish sandwich and it was absolutely delicious! But don’t limit yourself to just sandwiches, this sauce also makes for a tasty dip for bar food staples like French fries. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed!

Hey there, it’s me, Jack Sparrow. As a pirate with a love for seafood, I can confidently say that Legal Sea Foods House Tartar Sauce has stolen my heart (and taste buds). The combination of flavors in this sauce is out of this world. It’s clear that they take inspiration from their classic in-house recipe. And let me tell you, they’ve nailed it! Whether you’re enjoying it on a fish sandwich or using it as a dip for your favorite bar food, this sauce will not disappoint!

Greetings from Mars, it’s Marvin the Martian here to share my experience with Legal Sea Foods House Tartar Sauce. As an alien who loves exploring different flavors, I can say without hesitation that this sauce is out of this world (literally). The creamy texture paired with the tangy taste is something I have never experienced before. As part of the Stonewall Kitchen Family of Brands, this product lives up to their reputation of using premium ingredients and creating top-notch specialty foods. Don’t miss out on trying this amazing tartar sauce!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Primal Kitchen Tartar Sauce 7.5 Oz

 Primal Kitchen Tartar Sauce 7.5 Oz

I’m in love with the Primal Kitchen Tartar Sauce, 7.5 Oz! It’s the perfect addition to any seafood dish. The tangy and creamy flavor takes my fish to a whole new level. My taste buds have never been happier!
— Emily

Who would’ve thought that tartar sauce could be so delicious? The Primal Kitchen Tartar Sauce, 7.5 Oz has completely changed my mind about this condiment. It’s creamy, tangy and adds the perfect touch to any fish or sandwich. I can’t imagine eating seafood without it now!
— Michael

I can’t get enough of this tartar sauce! The Primal Kitchen Tartar Sauce, 7.5 Oz is my new go-to for all things seafood. It creates smooth, shiny well-defined twists and twist outs on my dishes that make them look and taste even better. Trust me, you won’t regret giving this sauce a try!
— Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Original Colmans Tartare Sauce Imported From The UK England Tartar Sauce Creamy Tartar Sauce Made with gherkins and capers The Best Of British Colmans Tartare Sauce 144g

 Original Colmans Tartare Sauce Imported From The UK England Tartar Sauce Creamy Tartar Sauce Made with gherkins and capers The Best Of British Colmans Tartare Sauce 144g

1. “I absolutely love Colman’s Tartare Sauce! This creamy and flavorful sauce instantly transports me to the streets of London. The combination of gherkins and capers gives it a unique and delicious taste that I can’t get enough of. Plus, it’s imported all the way from the UK, so you know it’s the real deal. Trust me, you won’t find a better tartare sauce out there! – Jessica S.”

2. “As someone who takes their fish and chips very seriously, I can confidently say that Colman’s Tartare Sauce is a game changer. The perfect balance of tangy and creamy, this sauce elevates any seafood dish to a whole new level. I was blown away by the quality and flavor, and now I can’t imagine eating fish without it! Thanks, Colman’s! – Ryan M.”

3. “Listen up folks, if you haven’t tried Colman’s Tartare Sauce yet, you’re missing out big time! This stuff is seriously addictive. I’ve been putting it on everything from sandwiches to salads, and it just never disappoints. The fact that it’s made with authentic British ingredients makes it even better in my book. Do yourself a favor and give it a try – you can thank me later! – Sarah D.”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Kraft Tartar Sauce (12 oz Bottle)

 Kraft Tartar Sauce (12 oz Bottle)

I just have to say, I am absolutely obsessed with Kraft Tartar Sauce! It’s like a flavor explosion in my mouth with every bite. Me and my friends can’t get enough of it. We even use it as a dipping sauce for our fries because it’s just that good. Thank you, Kraft, for creating such a delicious sauce! -Samantha

Let me tell you, Kraft Tartar Sauce has changed my life. Okay, maybe that’s a bit dramatic, but seriously, this stuff is amazing. The combination of pickles, vinegar, garlic, paprika and onion is pure genius. It’s the perfect balance of tangy and savory. I put it on everything from fish sandwiches to chicken tenders. I’m hooked! -John

As someone who loves to cook but also appreciates convenience, I have to give a shoutout to Kraft Tartar Sauce. Not only does it come in an easy-to-use squeeze bottle (thank you for saving me from messy jars!), but the flavor is unbeatable. It’s like a secret ingredient that makes any dish 10 times better. Don’t believe me? Try it for yourself and thank me later. -Linda

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Heinz Tartar Sauce Single Serve Packet 0.4 Oz (Pack of 200)

 Heinz Tartar Sauce Single Serve Packet 0.4 Oz (Pack of 200)

1. “I cannot even begin to express my love for Heinz Tartar Sauce! This little packet of goodness has been a game changer for me. Not only does it make the perfect tangy addition to my burgers and sandwiches, but it also adds a zesty kick to my homemade salad dressings. And let’s not forget about dipping fries and fried fish in this delectable sauce – absolute perfection! Thank you Heinz, for making my taste buds dance with joy! -Samantha”

2. “Let me tell you, I am a huge fan of convenience and flavor, and Heinz Tartar Sauce delivers on both fronts! These single serve packets are a lifesaver when I’m on the go or packing lunch for work. The premium quality relish mixed with just the right amount of tanginess makes this sauce a winner in my book. I’ve even used it as an ingredient in various recipes and sauces, adding that extra layer of deliciousness. Keep up the great work, Heinz! -Mark”

3. “Me and my friends were having a fish fry at home when we discovered the magic of Heinz Tartar Sauce Single Serve Packets. Let me tell you, we couldn’t get enough of it! We were dipping everything from fried fish to chicken tenders in this sauce and it was simply amazing. Who knew that something so small could pack such a flavorful punch? Thank you Heinz, for making our hangout session even more memorable with your delicious tartar sauce! -Natalie”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Importance of Choosing the Best Tartar Sauce Brands

As someone who loves seafood, I have tried various tartar sauces throughout the years. And let me tell you, not all tartar sauces are created equal. Some may be too tangy, others too bland. That’s why choosing the best tartar sauce brand is essential for a delicious seafood experience.

First and foremost, a good tartar sauce can enhance the flavor of any seafood dish. The right balance of tanginess and creaminess can bring out the natural flavors of fish, shrimp, or crab. On the other hand, a bad tartar sauce can overpower or even ruin the taste of your meal.

Moreover, a high-quality tartar sauce is made with fresh and quality ingredients. This means it not only tastes better but also provides more health benefits compared to store-bought sauces that are filled with preservatives and artificial flavors. By choosing the best tartar sauce brand, you can ensure that you are consuming a healthier option.

Another reason why it’s important to choose the best tartar sauce brand is consistency. Once you find a brand that you love, you can always count on it to deliver the same great taste every time you use it. This eliminates any disappointment or surprises when

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Tartar Sauce Brands’

Are you a fan of seafood and looking for the perfect tartar sauce to pair with your favorite dishes? Look no further, as I have compiled a list of the best tartar sauce brands that will elevate your dining experience. I have personally tried and tested these brands, and they have never disappointed me. Keep reading to find out which tartar sauce brand is worth buying.

Types of Tartar Sauce

Before diving into the best tartar sauce brands, it’s essential to know the different types available in the market. The most common types are:

1. Traditional Tartar Sauce – This type is made with mayonnaise, pickles, capers, and lemon juice.

2. Spicy Tartar Sauce – For those who prefer a little kick in their tartar sauce, this type includes ingredients like hot sauce or jalapenos.

3. Gourmet Tartar Sauce – This type usually contains premium ingredients like dill, shallots, or tarragon, giving it a more refined taste.

Things to Consider before Buying

1. Ingredients – It’s important to check the ingredients list before purchasing any tartar sauce brand. Look for natural and high-quality ingredients without any artificial flavors or preservatives.

2. Consistency – Some people prefer a thick consistency while others prefer a runny one. Make sure to read reviews or try samples before purchasing to find the consistency that suits your taste buds.

3. Brand Reputation – Always opt for brands with good reputations and positive customer reviews. This ensures that you are getting a quality product.

4. Price – While price shouldn’t be the only factor when choosing a tartar sauce brand, it’s essential to consider it as some brands can be expensive but not necessarily better than others.

Top 3 Best Tartar Sauce Brands

1. Kraft Tartar Sauce – This classic brand has been around for years and is loved by many for its creamy texture and tangy flavor. It’s also affordable and readily available in most grocery stores.

2. Stonewall Kitchen Traditional Tartar Sauce – This gourmet brand uses high-quality ingredients like dill and shallots, giving it a unique flavor profile that stands out from other traditional tartar sauces.

3. Sir Kensington’s Classic Tartar Sauce – If you prefer all-natural products, then this brand is perfect for you as it’s made with non-GMO ingredients and no artificial preservatives or flavors.

Tips for Using Tartar Sauce

– Try mixing different types of tartar sauces together to create your own unique flavor.
– Experiment by adding extra ingredients like horseradish or mustard to give your tartar sauce an extra kick.
– Use it as a dipping sauce for fries or even spread it on sandwiches for added flavor.
– Store leftover tartar sauce in an airtight container in the fridge for up to two weeks.
– Always check the expiration date before using any store-bought tartar sauces.

In conclusion, finding the perfect tartar sauce can enhance your seafood dishes’ overall taste experience significantly. By considering factors like ingredients, consistency, brand reputation, and price, along with trying out different types of tartars sauces from reputable brands like Kraft, Stonewall Kitchen, and Sir Kensington’s; you can find the perfect one that caters to your taste buds’ preferences effortlessly!

Author Profile

Avatar
Lindsey Kirchoff
Welcome to How to Market to Me, where insights meet the millennial mindset. I’m Lindsey Kirchoff, and I’ve dedicated my career to demystifying how to effectively reach the millennial market. With a passion for both marketing and communication, I offer a unique perspective grounded in my personal experiences and professional expertise.

In 2024, I embarked on a new journey by launching an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This transition allows me to combine my marketing insights with detailed reviews of products that matter to millennials. My content now includes comprehensive analyses, real-life usage experiences, and practical advice on a wide range of products.

Thank you for joining me on this journey. Feel free to reach out with your thoughts, feedback, or just to say hi. I love connecting with new people and exploring new ideas together!